S-Corp vs LLC: What Most Business Owners Get Wrong
POV: Your friend tells you, “I have an S-Corp—you should get one too.”
It sounds legit, right? Except… there’s a catch. An S-Corp isn’t actually a type of business. It’s not a legal entity at all. It’s a tax election—and that detail matters more than most people realize.
If you’re thinking about forming a business and you’re confused about S-Corps, LLCs, and corporations, here’s what you need to know before you file anything.
What is an S-Corp?
An S-corporation (S-Corp) is a tax status, not a business structure. You can’t “form” an S-Corp from scratch. Instead:
You first form a corporation or a Limited Liability Company (LLC) under state law.
Then you elect to have that entity taxed as an S-Corp with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
This election can provide certain tax advantages—like potentially reducing self-employment taxes—but it also comes with strict rules.
S-Corp vs LLC: The Key Difference
An LLC is a legal entity created under state law. It protects your personal assets from business debts and liabilities.
An S-Corp is simply a tax classification that an LLC (or corporation) can choose for IRS purposes. It doesn’t change the fact that your business is still an LLC or corporation under state law.
Think of it like clothing: Your legal entity is the person. The S-Corp election is the outfit they’re wearing.
Why S-Corp Confusion Can Cost You
Too many entrepreneurs skip straight to “I want an S-Corp” because they heard it’s better for taxes. But here’s the problem:
If you don’t first form a legal entity, you can’t elect S-Corp status.
Choosing S-Corp status without understanding the IRS requirements can trigger penalties, back taxes, or loss of the election.
When an S-Corp Election Makes Sense
While every business is different, here are some scenarios where an S-Corp election might be worth considering:
Your business consistently nets enough income to benefit from splitting owner pay between salary and distributions.
You’re ready to handle payroll and extra IRS filing requirements.
You’ve talked with a CPA or tax pro who confirms the S-Corp election will actually save you money.
When to Stick with Standard LLC Taxation
For many small businesses, especially in the first year or two, the default LLC tax classification (sole proprietor for single-member LLCs or partnership for multi-member LLCs) is simpler and more cost-effective.
You can always elect S-Corp status later once your business income supports it.
Bottom Line: Legal Entity First, Tax Election Second
If you take nothing else from this article, remember this: An S-Corp is not a business structure.
Start with the right legal foundation—whether that’s an LLC or corporation—then decide if the S-Corp election is right for your tax strategy.
Ready to form your LLC the right way?
We’ll help you choose the right legal structure for your business and make sure your filings are done correctly.
Check out our Legalmiga® Membership or à la carte legal services for tailored support.
Book a consultation here.